Dr, Herbert M. Cole, professor emeritus,
University of California, Santa Barbara : 2013 review of Dogon Images
& Traditions
The
Dutch photographer, Huib Blom, has illustrated and written a splendid
large book: Dogon: Images and
Traditions, which surveys in considerable depth the celebrated
landscapes, architectures, and arts of the Dogon peoples, who
themselves appear in dozens of the hundreds of superb black and white
photographs. The plurals in the previous sentence are deliberate, for
Blom has carefully avoided essentializing Dogon culture as a single
fixed entity, for example, by falling into the “Griaule trap” which
smoothly, seductively codified Dogon thought and cosmology in his
Conversations with Ogotemmeli. (Dieu
d'Eau, entretiens avec Ogotemméli, 1948). Notably, Blom omits
this book in his bibliography. Rather, we are presented, in photographs
and text, with some of the nearly endless complexities of things and
activities Dogon, whether wall paintings, caves, migrations, family
names, art styles, sacrifices, masks, roof-scapes, rituals, people,
buildings, shrines, or spectacular landscapes. Moreover, Blom’s fresh
exploring eye as a sensitive photographer -- on some 20 trips to Mali
over some 20 years -- informs nearly every page of the book, which is
thankfully cliché-free in dealing with a culture, or better, a related
congeries of cultures, that have fascinated professionals and amateurs
for many decades. The book provides ample contextual explications of
Dogon art, ritual, ceremony, and everyday life in vivid pictures and
well written texts.
Not surprisingly, the great impact and strength of the book are its
photographs; they are sharp, well composed, original, unexpected,
edifying and often eloquent, which is to say poetic and poignant
without being sentimental or romantic. Many pictures are redolent with
history, in the textures and surfaces of buildings, rock outcroppings,
and cave contents. It is not uncommon for many to envisage Dogon and
other African cultures – so different from those of Europe or America
-- as timeless and frozen, but Blom avoids that trap too, for example
by showing a rock drawing of a bicycle along with many other earlier
drawings and paintings on rock surfaces that I for one have never seen
before. We spot a modern suitcase long with traditional pottery. He
explores remote parts of Dogon country difficult of access, and also
shows varied views of the dominant geographical feature of this
dramatic landscape, the Bandiagara escarpment. Some may complain that
the photographs are exclusively black and white, but I find that medium
strong, and appropriate to Blom’s comprehensive view of Dogon life and
topography, as it preserves some of the mystique that many of us feel
when confronted with the subjects he records. And frankly, some of his
fine pictures do have a romantic tinge, such as the final double-page
spread of a lone person standing in a spectacular sculptural complex of
bedrock, eroded by nature and the hands of men and probably women, or
another double-page image of a manifestly old, smoothly rounded
building that looks very much like a gigantic ancient ceramic sculpture
(pages 130 &131).
The book’s text (in English and French), is informative and well
researched; it is divided into five chapters that begin an excellent
map. The first outlines pre-Dogon cultures, Toloy and Tellem, with
cliff-side caves, their interiors and artifacts, pointing out clearly
the heterogeneity of Dogon migrations of disparate populations from
different regions, plus varied ceramic wares, woodcarving,
architecture, and lifeways. The second chapter – A Wide Territory --
surveys regional landscapes and art styles in the three major zones:
cliff top villages, those on the Seno plain below the escarpment, and
others that appear to climb the cliff, linking some specific sculptural
styles, according to the Leloup canon, to specific named regions. Here
we are introduced to further differences among areas and subgroups, to
the relationships among Dogon, Djenne and Djenneke with similar forms
and styles. Blom does not skirt the historical complexities of the
greater region and he is careful to cite his sources. There are
seventeen separate texts for as many regions, and varied examples of
buildings and sculptures for many of them, myths and stories of
migration and conflict, of tribes, languages, and families. This is the
longest chapter, and contains well thought out information on many
subjects and historical relationships. The complexity of Dogon history
is in relationships among varied Dogon communities themselves, as well
as with Mossi, Samo, Songhay, Bamana, and Fulani peoples over the
centuries.
Chapter three, on architecture and religion, is also rich as it
discusses specialist personnel (priests and smiths), building types,
cults, altars, and shrines – and as in all parts of the book --
illuminated by fine photographs. Chapter four – funerary rites – is
fairly short, like the first chapter. The final chapter, on masks and
masquerades, gives a valuable overview without being at all exhaustive
even as major mask types are enumerated and illustrated both in studio
shots and in field photographs. Here and earlier there are discussions
of the sixty-year funerary ceremony and its focus on the Great Mask,
which is not danced, as well as the origin of masking. There are
sixteen short essays on varied aspects of masking, costume, and masks
themselves. After a short but appropriate conclusion – about fairly
recent changes -- the book ends with a useful glossary and a good
bibliography.
The art works illustrated are as well chosen as the photographs, and I
am again struck, as I have been over the years, with the uncanny
parallels between the shapes and textured surfaces of Dogon sculptures
and those of both buildings and the landscape itself, including the
trees – relationships stated repeatedly in the photographs. The book’s
design also features several fine facing pages: a granary door showing
crocodiles, in both a studio shot and in context, and other similarly
paired pictures: clay figurines, a figurated ritual vessel, a smith’s
bellows, and several masks. Another pair juxtaposes a fine sculpture of
a standing female against a black background opposite a page showing an
actual standing woman facing the same direction but at some distance
across a roof-scape, silhouetted against a light sky. The text on
funerary rites is framed by pictures of a cloth-enshrouded corpse being
pulled up to its cliff-side cave. Throughout, the close-ups and distant
shots are equally telling, and the photographs also seem to reveal the
weather, the dust, and the time of day, deep shadows and searing
sunlight. The pictures of people show them as lively, interesting, and
intelligent.
There are many surprises and treats here, verbal and
visual insights. The book is to be savored, as the texts speak to and
deepen the photographs, which are to be studied for detailed
information that careful looking rewards. Clearly this book is a labor
of love, its own strong artistry echoing the varied aesthetics of Dogon
arts and architectures in their magnificent environments.
|